Homework, digital exercises, reminders, contingency management, and measurement-based care: what the research supports, what it doesn't, and how to build a program clinicians will use.
Key takeaways
Between-session engagement is the work patients do between appointments: practicing skills, tracking mood, completing assessments, taking medication, and showing up for the next visit. For executives and clinical directors in outpatient behavioral health, CCBHCs, IOPs, and SUD programs, it is where outcomes are won or lost, because a weekly session covers a single hour of a patient's week. This guide reviews what the evidence says about homework, digital exercises, reminders, contingency management, and measurement-based care, where the evidence is thin, and how to build a between-session program your clinicians will actually use.
Verity for Patients turns the time between visits into structured, visible activity that the care team can see and act on:
The table below is an Illustration, not a statistic. It uses simple, hypothetical numbers to show how much of a patient's week happens outside the session.
| Illustration, not a statistic | Hypothetical weekly outpatient patient |
|---|---|
| Hours in a week | 168 |
| Hours asleep (7 per night) | 49 |
| Hours in session | 1 |
| Waking hours outside session | 118 |
| Share of waking hours spent with a clinician | Under 1% |
| Program of 200 patients: 10 more patients stay for 6 more visits at $120 each | $7,200 in visits that would otherwise be lost |
Skills are learned in the session but used in the other 118 hours. Retention, outcomes, and quality scores all depend on what happens there.
Here is how each common approach holds up, from the strongest evidence to the weakest.
Homework is one of the best-studied between-session tools. A meta-analysis of 17 CBT studies with 2,312 clients found a large relationship between how much homework clients completed and their outcomes (g = 0.79 at posttreatment), and the quality of the work mattered too. The practical lesson is not "assign more homework." It is to assign specific tasks, make them easy to do, and review them at the next session so patients know someone is paying attention.
Routine assessments between sessions turn a patient's week into data the clinician can use. A 2021 meta-analysis of 58 studies and about 21,700 patients found that progress feedback had a small effect on symptom reduction (d = 0.15) and a small favorable effect on dropout, including for patients who were not on track. The effect is modest, but it applies across a whole caseload and supports measures such as CCBHC depression remission at six months.
Contingency management has some of the strongest evidence in addiction treatment. A JAMA Psychiatry meta-analysis of studies with more than 10,000 patients receiving medication for opioid use disorder found that CM improved abstinence and also improved therapy attendance and medication adherence. The same principle, reinforcing a specific behavior soon after it happens, can be applied to attendance and exercise completion. Our contingency management software buyer's guide covers program design and compliance.
Apps help on average, but modestly. A 2024 meta-analysis of 176 randomized trials in World Psychiatry found that mental health apps reduced depression (g = 0.28) and generalized anxiety (g = 0.26) compared with controls, though only 6% of studies met all risk-of-bias criteria. The bigger problem is that patients stop using them. An analysis of 93 popular mental health apps found median 15-day retention of 3.9% and 30-day retention of 3.3%.
Digital work sticks when a person is involved. A meta-analysis of 22 studies found that guidance significantly increased completion of computerized mental health interventions, and full completion rates were 12% higher in guided groups. For clinics, guidance does not need to be long. It means a clinician who assigns the exercise, sees whether it was done, and mentions it in session.
Reminders by text, phone, or app reliably reduce missed appointments, and the wording matters. Our guide on how to reduce no-shows in behavioral health reviews the trials. The same messages can prompt an exercise, an assessment, or a medication check-in.
Points, streaks, levels, and rewards are popular for a reason: they encourage people to keep using a tool. But a systematic review of 50 gamified mental health apps and technologies found that researchers mostly used gamification to encourage use, and the review did not assess effectiveness. Treat gamification as a delivery method. It works best when it rewards activities with their own evidence, such as attendance, homework, assessments, and medication adherence.
Want clinicians to see what happens between sessions?See how Verity for Patients works.
Between-session engagement works when it is specific, easy, reinforced, and reviewed. The evidence is strongest for homework that clinicians review, routine outcome feedback, contingency management, reminders, and human guidance. It is weakest for standalone apps and rewards that are not tied to clinical behaviors. Book a demo to see how Verity for Patients connects exercises, assessments, rewards, and alerts to your care team and EHR.
Verity works with any EHR and connects to 200+ systems through API or secure file transfer, so appointments, attendance, and assessment results flow automatically.
It is everything a patient does for their treatment between appointments: practicing skills, completing exercises, tracking mood, taking medication, completing assessments, and attending the next visit. Because a weekly session covers only one hour, this time shapes most of a patient's progress, retention, and measurable outcomes.
Yes. A meta-analysis of 17 CBT studies with 2,312 clients found a large relationship between how much homework clients completed and their outcomes. The quality of the work mattered too. Results are best when homework is specific, easy to complete, and reviewed by the clinician at the next session.
Modestly, on average. A 2024 meta-analysis of 176 trials found small reductions in depression and anxiety. Most patients stop using standalone apps within weeks, though, and guidance from a person improves completion. Apps work best when a clinician assigns the activity and reviews it in session.
Partly. Gamification is widely used to keep patients engaged, but there is little direct evidence that it improves outcomes on its own. Its value comes from reinforcing activities that do have evidence, such as attendance, homework, assessments, and medication adherence, which is the same principle behind contingency management.
Track completion, not logins. Measure assigned exercises completed before the next session, on-time assessment completion, weekly active patients, retention for engaged versus unengaged patients, outcome change, and alert response time. Review the numbers monthly by program and clinician, and adjust the behaviors you target.